Meta All Microsites Pixel

The 9 Best Custom Home Builders in Sanibel, Florida

9 Min Read

Sanibel is known for its sandy beaches along the Gulf of Mexico. This stunning coastal setting calls for a custom built home that lets you appreciate the natural beauty of the area. Working with the best custom home builders in Sanibel, Florida, will help you stay on schedule.

Whether you’d like to build a new home or update an existing one, these builders will offer reliable services that meet your needs. Our team curated this list of the best custom home builders in Sanibel, Florida, using a set of criteria that includes press features, awards, principal background, portfolio, and services.

BCB Homes

3696 Enterprise Ave. Suite 100, Naples, FL 34104

Homebuilding is a deeply personal process for many clients. It’s important to find a custom home builder who will be just as invested in your project. BCB Homes cultivates relationships with clients long before construction begins. It starts the moment you make contact with the company and lasts long after site clean-up and walkthrough. With a strong commitment to craftsmanship and quality, they build homes that are easy and pleasurable to live in.

BCB Homes has been in business for 28 years, staying rooted in their founding principles while applying innovative techniques and ideas. They’ve built some of the most celebrated custom homes in Sanibel, Naples, Marco Island, and the surrounding northern territories, including Mediterranean and Contemporary-style homes with high ceilings, glass walls, and other upscale features. They specialize in residential construction, remodels, renovations, additions, and estate management services to meet the needs of homeowners in need of reliable and experienced builders. They also offer first-rate consulting and investigation services including indoor air quality (IAQ) testing, water penetration testing, HVAC system management, and exterior building surveys using the latest tools and equipment.

BCB Homes grants access to a diverse pool of professionals to deliver a wide range of custom solutions. As a testament to their skill and professionalism, the company received the 2019 National Association of Home Builders (NAHB) Silver Award for Best Interiors of a Custom Home and the 2019 Sand Dollar Award for Product Design of the Year in the Single Family Homes Category.

Benchmark General Contractors

16836 McGregor Blvd., Fort Myers, FL 33908

Eco-living is a new luxury, and no one does it better than Benchmark General Contractors. The company has a Leadership in Environmental Energy and Design (LEED) AP certification, making it an expert in energy-efficient design and construction. Its portfolio includes some of the finest contemporary, modern, and Mediterranean homes in Sanibel. These homes were designed with indoor air quality (IAQ) and natural light in mind so clients can enjoy safe and healthy spaces that enhance their lifestyle. 

A leader in sustainable and green building practices, the company spares no expense when it comes to quality design and construction. With over 25 years in business, it has also developed an in-depth knowledge of key areas like local permitting procedures, windstorm protection, and floodplain construction. This allows them to build energy-efficient homes that can withstand the Southwest Florida climate. Proving its success, the firm has been featured in the Sanibel-Captiva Islander and Florida Weekly. Company President Mark Anderson was also named 2018 Business Person of the Year by the Sanibel Captiva Chamber.  

PGI Homes

218 Cape Coral Pkwy. W, Cape Coral, FL 33914

For PGI Homes, good design goes beyond aesthetics and transcends trends. It is about optimizing space to build healthier and happier communities. The company has been serving clients in Sanibel and the surrounding areas for more than 17 years. Its projects include contemporary and Mediterranean-style homes that offer seamless indoor to outdoor living. 

With tropical landscaping, spacious driveways and elegantly appointed outdoor spaces, these homes epitomize laid-back luxury in a coastal setting. As a bespoke home builder, PGI Homes offers no less than unique home building solutions that reflect a client’s personal style and preferences. This is done through a fully integrated design process. The company also provides access to a diverse team of craftspeople including engineers, designers, carpenters, drywallers, and flooring specialists. 

From site evaluation and drafting to construction and site clean-up, the company’s meticulous attention allows them to deliver the best service possible. PGI Homes has been featured in Florida Home Builder and Harbor Style. President and Founder Anthony Farhat is a winner of the Young Entrepreneur of the Year Award and was featured in the Top 40 Under 40 list by the Gulfcoast Business Review

Luxury Home Solutions

12244 Treeline Ave. Suite 7, Fort Myers, FL 33913

What defines luxury? For Luxury Home Solutions, it’s about substance, quality and design that transcends passing trends. With more than 40 years in business, LHS offers new construction and remodeling to discerning clients who know what they want out of a project. The company collaborates with highly skilled designers, consultants, suppliers, and contractors to deliver high-value projects worthy of Sanibel’s idyllic coastal setting.   

It has worked on some of the most distinctive properties in and around the city, including single-family homes and condos. With an eye for Mediterranean and Contemporary-style architecture, LHS builds and renovates homes with artisanal skill as evident in custom ironwork, tilework, and woodwork. Some of its high-profile homes come equipped with bowling alleys, outdoor swimming pools and other lavish on-site amenities.

The company has built over 1,000 custom homes throughout Florida to date. Over 90% of their business comes from repeat clients and referrals a testament to its solid reputation and remarkable work. With several luxury home plans to choose from, the team makes it easier for clients to communicate their vision and get started on their dream project. The company combines extensive experience with strong design sensibility to bring dream homes to life.

Daniel Wayne Homes 

5961 Northland Rd. Unit #1, Fort Myers, FL 33905

No matter the price range or project specifications, all clients want the same thing – to stay on budget and on schedule without lowering their expectations. Daniel Wayne Homes gives you all that and more. As a custom and semi-custom builder with more than 25 years in the industry, the company takes a straightforward approach to project management and supervision. 

It fulfills its obligations through candid communication at each step of the process. It addresses issues that can potentially affect the costs, timelines, and final results of the project. By taking out the guesswork, it is able to deliver on time and as promised. This no-frills attitude and work style has helped the company become one of the most trusted names in residential construction. 

Its work can be found in some of Southwest Florida’s most prestigious communities. From Contemporary to Ranch-style homes, the company is known for “homes built with livability”, or well-thought-out living spaces designed for maximum comfort and functionality. These homes blend into their natural surroundings to enhance inhabitants’ quality of life. Some of the company’s awards include the 2012 Lee Building Industry Association Lee (BIA) Parade of Homes Award for Best Bath, Best Livability, Best Outdoor Living, and Best Pool for The Plantation at Horse Creek. 

Dan Hahn Custom Builders

1630 Periwinkle Way Ste. H, Sanibel, FL 33957

Dan Hahn Custom Home Builders knows it needs to build a good relationship with clients in order to build a good home. With this in mind, this Sanibel custom home builder makes it a priority to cultivate genuine and long-lasting relationships, not just with clients, but with craftspersons, suppliers, and subcontractors that make up its robust professional network. 

To maintain trust and goodwill, the company believes that regular communication is key. Listening closely to clients’ requirements and specifications allows them to build memorable custom homes that exceed expectations. With the client’s active involvement and participation, the firm is able to translate ideas into concrete results. This is what the company calls “The Hahn Difference”. The team takes a hands-on approach to home building and remodeling from design and planning to permitting and final construction. The result is a smooth experience for the client from start to finish. 

The company’s services include new construction and remodeling using the latest in green technology. As the company behind Southwest Florida’s finest Spanish Revival and Contemporary-style homes, it can upgrade any property green features like solar-heated pools. Dan Hahn Custom Builders has been featured in Florida Design, Gulfshore Life, and Grandeur

Calusa Construction

16010 OLD 41 N Unit 101, Naples, FL 34110

What sets luxury projects apart is the level of service and craftsmanship involved. Discerning clients are willing to pay a premium for the luxury experience with a skilled and attentive builder that’s willing to meet their every need. Calusa Construction is up to the task, focusing on quality and customer service to differentiate themselves from the competition. Its business philosophy, that a project’s total quality is built on exemplary craftsmanship at every level, speaks through the thoroughness of its work. President and project manager of the firm, Aidan Weir is a certified general contractor and home inspector with over 40 years of experience.

The company specializes in high-end residential construction and light commercial development. It is behind some of Southwest Florida’s finest luxury custom homes, renovations and commercial projects.  These include Traditional, Cottage and Mediterranean-inspired homes with custom millwork, glass railings, fire pits, ethanol fireplaces and other modern features. Its properties come with gourmet kitchens, spacious driveways, large outdoor spaces, and landscaped lawns that make day-to-day living more enjoyable and fulfilling. 

With skilled designers, carpenters, subcontractors, managers and superintendents, the company makes sure that the highest standards are met with each project. It works closely with leading suppliers and vendors so that clients have access to quality materials and labor.

M.A.B. Homes

16848 McGregor Blvd. Suite 110, Fort Myers, FL 33908

M.A.B. Homes understands that the custom home building process is deeply personal. This Fort Myers-based custom builder, therefore, offers bespoke solutions with stunning results. Its services include residential construction, remodels, additions, and estate management using its skilled team of architects, engineers, interior designers, subcontractors and project managers to complete each project. Some of its finest projects include Contemporary, Traditional, Modern and Transitional homes with lavish kitchens, spa-style bathrooms, and spacious balconies and observation decks. 

Company President and Owner Mark Barriball is directly involved in each project. With an extensive background in design, construction and planning, he brings over 15 years of experience to the table. Under his leadership, the company has earned certifications and accreditations from the Florida Home Builders Association (FHBA), National Association of Home Builders (NAHB) and Lee Building Industry Association (Lee BIA). 

DeSanctis Enterprises

26381 S. Tamiami Trail #138, Bonita Springs, FL 34134

For DeSanctis Enterprises, a custom home builder does more than build to specifications. It also builds to the needs and lifestyles of its customers. The company goes beyond cookie-cutter homes to deliver one-of-a-kind properties that reflect individuality. From lot selection to design, the company delivers fine custom homes to last for generations.  

With more than 35 years of experience, DeSanctis Enterprises specializes in architecture, new construction, construction management, remodeling, interior design and landscape design. From materials selection to design planning, the team will provide professional guidance to point the homeowner in the right direction.

The firm’s portfolio includes stunning Meditteranean, Spanish Revival, and Contemporary homes that offer the ultimate coastal lifestyle. With gourmet kitchens, custom wine displays, and tropical landscaping, these properties are among the finest in Southwest Florida. Aside from project managers, designers and craftspeople, the team also includes licensed real estate agents who can help find or sell a home in the Sanibel area.