Building your dream home can be a challenging task, given the logistics and financial challenges. Hiring a home builder will ease the process and ensure that the project is completed in accordance with the strictest standards and local codes. Old Tappan has a number of great custom home builders who know both the craft and the demands of the local community. We decided to feature the best custom home builders in Old Tappan, New Jersey.

To come up with this list, our team gathered a shortlist of local builders and assessed each with a set of criteria that evaluates each firm’s work history, capacity, and overall quality of work.

RTJ Construction

269 Idaho Street, Paramus, NJ 07652

RTJ Construction is an expert general contractor and a seasoned home builder known for its collaborative approach to the building process. RTJ specializes in new home construction, residential renovation, and property maintenance. Headed by industry veteran Rich Palmaccio, RTJ is anchored on the values of commitment, consistency, and reliability. These values have generated a repeat customer rate of over 80%. Homes such as the Bungalow home in the photo show RTJ’s commitment to the craft. The home includes a tasteful arrangement of neutral tones, stonework, and clean design elements. Simplicity is a prerequisite for elegance, as this house demonstrates.

Carbone Developers

40 Churchill Road, Old Tappan, NJ 07675

Carbone Developers has provided luxury home building and quality property improvement services for over 25 years. Joseph Carbone is an alumnus of Northeastern University Engineering. He brings in a wealth of experience and high regard for quality in every project. You can see all of it in the firm’s residential portfolio of residential properties, featuring homes in a wide range of scales and styles. The home pictured here is a straightforward estate with polished details and structure. Red brickwork, contrasted by white and gray details, defines the exterior of the home. This palette choice provides classical elegance and timelessness while balancing the latest in design techniques.

Corsair Construction

1 Executive Drive, Suite, LL100, Fort Lee, NJ 07024

Serving the Tri-State area with time-tested custom home building projects, Corsair Construction is a construction company bringing newer perspectives to the local construction scene. Corsair is experienced in servicing homes in Northern New Jersey, Westchester County, and Greenwich, Connecticut. The firm also knows the real estate market in the New York City Area. Principles Conrad and Dean Roncati bring their loaded resume to the company; they’ve collectively studied Economics, Real Estate Development, and Business at leading universities. 

The Corsair portfolio is a visual treat to those that favor forward-thinking design and robust architecture. The Modern home featured here an interesting property built on Pearl Court, Old Tappan. Nestled in the woodlands, this estate’s masterful use of mirrors, wood, and steel camouflage the home in the environment. The material selection is matched with a curvilinear façade and an asymmetrical structure, furthering the playful nature of the home. This home puts a spin on the luxury of privacy.

ECS Homes

285 Pascack Road, Suite #5 Township of Washington, NJ 07676

Known for its no-nonsense and seamless construction processes, ECS Homes is a remodeler and custom home builder fluent in the local design parlance and the needs of local homeowners. Mark Eleyan, ECS principal, is an authority in local construction. He forged many relationships with top-tier subcontractors and national brands. He has solidified his influence through his emphasis on the building process. The firm has completed a number of major renovations and home builds. The ECS portfolio includes a wide variety of home styles sporting the firm’s versatility and thorough knowledge of residential construction. The Craftsman home in the photo is among the firm’s most outstanding pieces of work. This estate combines the classical style with modern-day sensibilities, striking a balance between timelessness and contemporary elements.

RS Mannino Architects + Builders

38 Park Ave. 3rd Flr., Rutherford, NJ 07070

Combining experience in architecture, homebuilding, cabinetry, RS Mannino Architects + Builders is an integrated construction firm servicing Rutherford, Bergen County, and surrounding areas. The firm has built a trusted reputation for quality craftsmanship and professionalism. Company namesake and principal Rosario Mannino is a New Jersey native, affording him the professional and personal connection with the way construction is being carried out in the area. He studied Architecture at Florida Atlantic University and Construction Project Management at New York University. His guidance aligned the firm to be one of the area’s leading names in homebuilding. 

The firm’s versatility and strong track record are exemplified in the company portfolio, which features various home styles, including Modern, farmhouse, French, and mid-century modern. The featured French Normandy-style home is a treat for those who like the early 20th-century style. This home is in the sweet spot between comfort and luxury, thanks to its fine details and thoughtful arrangements. This estate features a limestone façade, a slate roof, half-round copper gutters, wrought iron balcony railings, and French casement and French doors.