Meta All Microsites Pixel

The Best Custom Home Builders in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania

17 Min Read
Photo for Dewson Construction Company

Last updated on July 19th, 2024 at 02:44 pm

Building a custom home in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, is a significant investment that requires finding the right contractor to bring your vision to life. The best custom home builders approach the construction process with precision and dedication, ensuring that every detail aligns with the client’s goals. These firms are committed to creating homes that not only meet but exceed industry standards, focusing on functionality, longevity, and each homeowner’s unique needs.

Philadelphia offers a diverse and vibrant real estate market with a population of 1.567 million and a median home value of $225,159. The cost of building a custom home in this city ranges from $100,000 to $500,000, with some projects reaching up to $750,000. At an average cost per square foot of $189.95, and with construction timelines typically extending up to 16 months, selecting a contractor who can manage both the financial and temporal demands of custom home building is crucial.

This article presents a curated list of the best custom home builders in Philadelphia. With 124 relevant contractors in the area, these selected firms stand out for their expertise, reliability, and dedication to quality. Choosing one of these top builders ensures that your home is constructed with meticulous attention to detail and a commitment to realizing your vision. Whether you’re dreaming of a modern urban dwelling or a classic suburban retreat, these custom home builders are equipped to create a space that reflects your unique tastes and needs.


Overview: The Best Custom Home Builders in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania

Contractor

Average Customer Satisfaction

Service Rating Score

Total Number of Reviews

Complaint Percentage

Sullivan Building & Design Group

4.9

5

15

1.7%

E.B. Mahoney Builders

4.9

5

7

2.9%

Dewson Construction Company

4.9

5

12

1.0%

McKee Builders

4.9

5

79

4.0%

Porter Construction, LLC

4.9

5

20

5.4%

Masada Custom Builders, Inc.

4.9

5

2

4.9%

McCoubrey/Overholser, Inc.

4.9

5

2

4.9%

Vaughan Building Company

4.9

5

2

4.9%

Megill Homes, Inc.

4.8

5

7

11.2%

Janiczek Homes, LLC

4.8

5

10

9.0%

Guidi Homes

4.7

5

7

11.2%

Rotelle Studio(e)

4.6

4

78

13.7%

Pohlig Custom Homes

4.6

3a4

13

18.6%

C. Raymond Davis & Sons, Inc.

4.4

4

7

27.9%

See Ranking Methodology at the bottom of this article to learn more.


Sullivan Building & Design Group

2320 Trumbauersville Rd., Quakertown, PA 18951

  Sullivan Building & Design Group

Year Established

1980

Services Provided

Custom Homes, Energy-Efficient Homes, Floor Plans, Green Building, Home Additions, Home Remodeling, House Plans, New Home Construction, Site Planning, Construction Drawings

Areas Served

Delaware Valley

What Customers Are Saying

Easy to Work With

Average Customer Satisfaction

4.9 (15 reviews)

Service Rating Score

5

Complaint Percentage

1.7%

Sullivan Building and Design Group provides homeowners in the Delaware Valley with the finest quality design and construction services. For the past 35 years, its team of skilled designers and craftspeople has built homes of all shapes and sizes, demonstrating thorough knowledge and expertise in their trades. As a result, many of the firm’s works have been praised by homeowners and recognized by industry organizations, such as the National Association of the Remodeling Industry and the National Kitchen and Bath Association. Among the renowned home builders in Philadelphia, it was also recognized in the Qualified Remodeler’s 2017 Master Design Awards for Silver Historic Renovation.

The modern loft is one of the firm’s most unique and striking work. The homeowners wanted the building to match their existing garage, enamored with the distinct look created by rusted metal. The firm decided to enhance the unique aesthetic by designing the exterior using contrasting colors and materials. The firm’s woodworking facility, Cider Press Woodworks, decorated the interior with furniture and fixtures created from sustainably harvested exotic woods.


E.B. Mahoney Builders

718 W Lancaster Ave., Bryn Mawr, PA 19010

  E.B. Mahoney Builders

Year Established

1926

Services Provided

Custom Home Building, Renovations/Additions, Retail/Commercial

Areas Served

Ardmore, Bala Cynwyd, Broomall, Bryn Mawr, Darby, Drexel Hill, Glenolden, Lansdowne, Malvern, Philadelphia, Rose Valley, Springfield, Clifton Heights, Haverford, Morton, Villanova, Southampton

Notable Project

Single family dwelling | 250 Ayrshire Dr, Villanova, PA, 19085 | $2881371

What Customers Are Saying

Top Notch Work

Average Customer Satisfaction

4.9 (7 reviews)

Service Rating Score

5

Complaint Percentage

2.9%

E.B. Mahoney Builders is the third generation of a construction company thoroughly dedicated to hard work and uncompromising quality. Today, there are homes on the Main Line and in surrounding communities that are products of the grit and determination of a company that endured a depression, a world war, and everything in between. Many of these homes have been recognized by the Main Line Builders Association, allowing the firm to win various awards, such as Best Custom Home, Best Residential Renovation, and Builder of the Year. Among the many Philadelphia custom home builders, it was also awarded the 2022 Best in PA Living Custom Home of the Year, $1 to 3 million.

E.B. Mahoney Builders is currently headed by Edwin Mahoney, who is lauded by clients for his high level of precision, style, and quality of work. Edwin is the initial point of contact for every client and knows first-hand the progress of every project his firm undertakes. His commitment to his clients is steadfast, and he has demonstrated genuine care in listening to them and working towards their goals.

One of its most notable projects is a colonial home that blends old-world craftsmanship and modern convenience, striking a balance between past and present. The building boasts an intricate stonework exterior, vaulted ceilings with stunning archways and columns, and a wall of windows that frame the custom-landscaped gardens.


Dewson Construction Company

7 S Lincoln St., Wilmington, DE 19805

  Dewson Construction Company

Year Established

1993

Services Provided

New Homes & Major Renovations, Coastal Homes, Additions and Remodeled Homes

Areas Served

Delaware, Greenville, Centreville, Wilmington, Delaware Beaches, Rehoboth Beach, Lewes, Bethany, Fenwick Island, Pennsylvania, West Chester, Chadds Ford, Avondale, Kennett Square, Main Line, Chesapeake (MD) Bay Area, Avalon/Stone Harbor, NJ

What Customers Are Saying

Impressive Quality Work

Average Customer Satisfaction

4.9 (29 reviews)

Service Rating Score

5

Complaint Percentage

1.0%

Commitment to client satisfaction has fueled Dewson Construction Company’s success in building and renovating custom homes. The firm has always worked with its clients, focusing on open communication, efficient project management, careful budgeting and scheduling, and attentively overseeing subcontractors, suppliers, and vendors. 

Due to this meticulousness, Dewson Construction Company has amassed an impressive portfolio featuring different homes in and around Delaware and Southeastern Pennsylvania. These outstanding homes have earned the firm several awards, such as Regal Awards from the Home Builders Association of Delaware, and were also featured in various publications, such as USA Today, Philadelphia Inquirer, and Remodeling Magazine.

One of its notable projects involved building a custom home, a carriage house, and a pool house on 20 acres of rolling hills in Chester County. Featuring elaborate stonework and spacious interiors, every corner of the family home manifests elegance and intricacy. The wood, brick, stone flooring, and decorative moldings and trim provide a handsome rustic design, while the neutral and earthy color scheme creates an overall warm and organic atmosphere.


McKee Builders

940 W Sproul Rd., Springfield Township, Delaware County, PA 19064

  McKee Builders

Year Established

1948

Services Provided

Home Building, Quick Delivery Homes, Energy Saving

Areas Served

New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Delaware, Maryland

Notable Project

Single family dwelling atwood | 424 Contemplation Way, Middletown, DE, 19709 | $375000

What Customers Are Saying

Good Quality Construction, Timely, Informative, Communicative

Average Customer Satisfaction

4.9 (79 reviews)

Service Rating Score

5

Complaint Percentage

4.0%

McKee Builders has been building homes in Pennsylvania, Delaware, Maryland, and New Jersey for over 70 years. Initially a heating and air conditioning contractor, the firm later focused on apartment development for older tenants. McKee Builders built more than 500 units, which it still owns and manages. Since then, the firm has been recognized as a pioneer in adult 55-plus housing, and it stayed resolute in building communities with homes of the highest quality, great value, and irresistible appeal.

Clients take pride in their homes because of their distinctive architecture, interesting locations, and innovative designs. Additionally, because the firm builds to the highest energy efficiency standards, its homes provide ultimate comfort and significant savings. Thanks to this care, McKee Builders has won various awards, including Best Single Family Home under 1,700 sq. ft. from the National Association of Home Builders, and been recognized by many industry organizations and media outlets, such as Good Morning America.


Porter Construction

129 Center Mill Rd., Chadds Ford, PA 19317

  Porter Construction, LLC

Year Established

1997

Services Provided

New Home Construction, Renovation, General Contracting, Interior Design

Areas Served

Delaware, Pennsylvania, New Jersey

What Customers Are Saying

Excellent Work

Average Customer Satisfaction

4.9 (20 reviews)

Service Rating Score

5

Complaint Percentage

5.4%

A home built by Porter Construction embodies the perfect marriage of refinement and value. The general contracting company has been creating high-quality, long-lasting single-family homes for decades. The extensive knowledge and expertise of its professionals are reflected in the stunning homes they build and the recognition they have received from various organizations and publications, like Philadelphia Magazine, Delaware Today, and Main Line Today.

One of the leading home builders in Philadelphia, Porter Construction builds homes upon the visions and unique goals of individual homeowners. The team partners with its clients, aligning critical design elements and architectural requirements. Additionally, Porter Construction combines traditional designs and innovative approaches, integrating modern convenience with classic elements to create simultaneously novel and timeless homes. Every step in the building process is overseen by a meticulous project manager and the firm’s principal, Scott Porter, to ensure that every task is done up to standard and quality.


Masada Custom Builders

316 S 7th St., Philadelphia, PA 19106

  Masada Custom Builders, Inc.

Year Established

1987

Services Provided

Custom Homes, Energy-Efficient Homes, Floor Plans, Historic Building Conservation, Home Extensions, New Home Construction, Site Planning, Site Preparation, Sustainable Design, Universal Design

Areas Served

Philadelphia, New Jersey, Delaware

Notable Project

New construction single family residence four story as per approved zoning plans including pilot house roof deck and finished basement | 613 Queen St, Philadelphia, PA, 19147 | $500000

What Customers Are Saying

Amazing Attention to Detail. Awesome Design

Average Customer Satisfaction

4.9 (2 reviews)

Service Rating Score

5

Complaint Percentage

4.9%

Whether it is a new construction, a remodel of an existing home, or a complete renovation of a historical property, Masada Custom Builders excels in bringing together different elements into a single vision. The firm has built some of the most beautiful homes in Philadelphia and throughout the Northeastern United States. One of the top custom home builders in Philadelphia, it is led by the design-build talents Isaac Ohayon and Naomi Alter-Ohayon, who have comprehensive experience in architecture, construction, and design.

Homes built by Masada Custom Builders are renowned for their high-end designs and world-class imported materials. Many feature contemporary elements and spacious floor plans, as well as natural lighting and hand-crafted finishes. From architecture and design to cabinetry and appliances, everything about the firm’s custom homes exudes quality, integrity, and inspiration.


McCoubrey/Overholser Building Construction

6839 Germantown Ave., Philadelphia, PA 19119

  McCoubrey/Overholser, Inc.

Year Established

1989

Services Provided

Custom Homes, Energy-Efficient Homes, Green Building, Home Extensions, New Home Construction, Custom renovations

Areas Served

Delaware Valley

Notable Project

Erection of an attached structure for use as single-family household living. Sheeting and shoring as prescribed in geo tech report. Separate permits required for electrical mechanical and plumbing. | 610 Gate House Ln, Philadelphia, PA, 19118 | $1172000

What Customers Are Saying

Responsive

Average Customer Satisfaction

4.9 (2 reviews)

Service Rating Score

5

Complaint Percentage

4.9%

Based in the Mt. Airy neighborhood of Philadelphia, McCoubrey/Overholser Building Construction is a firm that has varied and extensive experience building in the Delaware Valley. Former clients vouch that McCoubrey/Overholser Building Construction has built its reputation on professionalism, service, and workmanship. Many say that the firm has consistently completed the most demanding building construction projects efficiently and within the set time and budget. Among the renowned Philadelphia new home builders, the studio was featured in a 2022 Dwell article.

The firm’s team of experts can create buildings of various styles, including traditional, contemporary, farmhouse, modern, and beach styles. In addition to custom homes, McCoubrey/Overholser Building Construction also constructs energy-efficient and green homes, home extensions, and custom renovations.


Vaughan Building Company

347 E Conestoga Rd., Wayne, PA 19087

  Vaughan Building Company

Year Established

1981

Services Provided

Custom Home Building and Design

Areas Served

Main Line
surrounding suburbs in Chester, Delaware, and Montgomery Counties

Notable Project

Single family dwelling | 109 Wheeler Ln, Villanova, PA, 19085 | $1045114

What Customers Are Saying

Excellent Experience

Average Customer Satisfaction

4.9 (2 reviews)

Service Rating Score

5

Complaint Percentage

4.9%

Named as one of America’s Best Builders by the National Association of Home Builders and Builder Magazine, Vaughan Building Company has created some of the most impressive new homes on the Main Line and surrounding counties of Chester, Montgomery, and Delaware Counties. For over 35 years, the firm has built award-winning homes with timeless architecture, modern amenities, and fine craftsmanship, which helped establish Vaughan Building Company as one of the country’s most respected custom home builders.

What clients like the most about the firm is that it provides personal guidance and step-by-step assistance from the get-go. From the selection manager to the construction foreman, everyone involved in the home-building process knows how to involve clients and address their needs and inquiries. They all aim to make the entire experience a pleasant and stress-free one for the homeowners while bringing their visions to life.


Megill Homes

330 Kennett Pike Suite #207, Chadds Ford, PA 19317

  Megill Homes, Inc.

Year Established

1969

Services Provided

Custom Home Building, Renovations

Areas Served

Pennsylvania, Delaware, Maryland

Notable Project

New residential building | 914 S Concord Rd, West Chester, PA, 19382 | $175000

What Customers Are Saying

Smooth Process,Timely, Beautiful Work

Average Customer Satisfaction

4.8 (7 reviews)

Service Rating Score

5

Complaint Percentage

11.2%

Wayne Megill started building homes with one thing in mind: listening to and following through on the homeowner’s wants and needs with the best products and techniques. This sentiment continues to drive Megill Homes to build custom spaces that exhibit the perfect marriage between form and function. Rather than follow the trend of using prefabricated components, the firm’s skilled craftspeople make use of durable materials and processes in building homes of lasting value.

The firm’s award-winning homes are characterized by attractive architecture and the best locations and settings. They also feature well-designed floor plans and durable components. Many of the firm’s homes have rustic, traditional, farmhouse, Victorian, and French influences, showcasing the extensive knowledge of the Megill Homes team. In addition, the firm is often listed as a selling feature in existing home sale advertising, strengthening the financial value of its homes in the marketplace.


Janiczek Homes

619 Conestoga Rd., Villanova, PA 19085

  Janiczek Homes, LLC

Year Established

1984

Services Provided

New Constructions, Renovations/Additions, Interiors, Kitchens and Bath, Green Building

Areas Served

Delaware Valley

What Customers Are Saying

Knowledgeable, Amazing Craftmanship

Average Customer Satisfaction

4.8 (10 reviews)

Service Rating Score

5

Complaint Percentage

9.0%

Janiczek Homes commits to each project a staff of skilled and experienced professionals—from talented artisans to meticulous design-build experts—and a thorough dedication to total client satisfaction. No matter how small or big the project may be, Janiczek Homes works with clients hand-in-hand to realize their home-building goals based on their needs and wants.

Over the years, Janiczek Homes has developed close working relationships with a number of trusted subcontractors, suppliers, and service providers based on their expertise, experience, and past performance. It also has ties with the Philadelphia Chapter of the American Institute of Architects and the National Association of Home Builders, which has given the firm numerous Pyramid, Pinnacle, and Judge’s Awards, from the Best Residential Innovation to the Best Custom Home, since 1999.


Guidi Homes

925 Harvest Dr. Suite #220, Blue Bell, PA 19422

  Guidi Homes

Year Established

1986

Services Provided

Custom Home Building, Renovations, Developement and Design, Commercial Construction

Areas Served

Greater Philadelphia Area

Notable Project

New Single-family Home | 137 Raven Hollow Dr, North Wales, PA, 19454 | $436400

What Customers Are Saying

Wonderful Quality Work, Knowledgeable, Efficient, Impeccable Work

Average Customer Satisfaction

4.7 (7 reviews)

Service Rating Score

5

Complaint Percentage

11.2%

Recognized as one of the Greater Philadelphia Area’s top custom home builders, Guidi Homes delivers customized homes characterized by unique architecture, intricate workmanship, and great value. Among the firm’s best projects are transitional, European, Mediterranean, colonial, farmhouse, and country-style buildings. 

For nearly four decades, the firm has continually impressed clients with its painstaking building process. It has ensured superior craftsmanship, the use of top-quality materials, and trusted methods in building livable spaces for its clients. 

The European country estate home was built in cooperation with the architect firm of McIntyre, Capron, and Associates for Philadelphia Magazine’s Design Home. It was constructed primarily for entertaining and features a wine cellar off of the dining room and butler’s pantry, an oversized dual-island kitchen open to the two-story great room, and a full bar, lounge, sauna, and billiards area in the lower level. The lower-level patio also features a timber-framed summer kitchen complete with grilling and entertaining areas.


Rotelle Studio(e)

1011 Ridge Rd., South Coventry, PA 19465

  Rotelle Studio(e)

Year Established

1989

Services Provided

Custom Home Building, Home Design, Land Development

Areas Served

Eastern Pennsylvania

Notable Project

Construction of new single family dwelling |
1135 Ginkgo Ln, Gladwyne, PA, 19035 | $811536

What Customers Are Saying

Unmatched Quality of Work, Good Communication, Phenomenal Team

Average Customer Satisfaction

4.6 (78 reviews)

Service Rating Score

4

Complaint Percentage

13.7%

Rotelle Studio(e) boasts a remarkable portfolio featuring custom-built luxury homes in and around Southeastern Pennsylvania. For over 25 years, the firm has specialized in tailoring homes to fit homeowners’ wants, needs, and lifestyles through its 10-step process, ensuring a meticulous approach to designing and building spaces with great value and curb appeal. The firm allows clients to create their own homes and lets them pick out its location among many available new home communities and home lots for sale across the region.

Each home built by Rotelle Studio(e) bears the same uncompromising attention to detail and quality that the firm devoted to the first home it constructed. The company remains small enough to give each client the personal attention they deserve yet large enough to deliver each project on time.

Among their best works is a home with four-bedroom, three-and-half-bath single-family with a two-story foyer, expansive kitchen, and family room. Clients can add a two-story stone fireplace in the spacious family room and a wet bar in the kitchen. The home also features a first-floor study and a large two-car garage.


Pohlig Custom Homes

274 Lancaster Ave. Suite #100, Malvern, PA 19355

  Pohlig Custom Homes

Year Established

1974

Services Provided

Custom Homes, Garage Building, Home Additions, Home Remodeling, New Home Construction, Pool House Design & Construction, Project Management

Areas Served

Main Line

Notable Project

Construction of single family home based on attached plans nan | Ivy Ln, Radnor Township, PA | $896682

What Customers Are Saying

Highest Quality Homes, Very Professional

Average Customer Satisfaction

4.6 (13 reviews)

Service Rating Score

4

Complaint Percentage

18.6%

For four decades, Pohlig Custom Homes has been creating luxury homes and communities in the Philadelphia Main Line, Jersey Shore, and beyond. It has built a steady clientele and strong relationships with trade partners and professionals, as well as a solid reputation in the industry as a responsible and efficient custom home builder. 

The firm’s processes and people are driven by its philosophy of integrity, particularly “doing things right and doing the right things.” This, alongside its dedication to building ethically and with great respect to the environment, helped the firm garner countless awards and recognitions, even being named by the National Association of Home Builders as the Best Custom Home Builder in America. Many consider this the most prestigious award in the residential building industry.

Each Pohlig home is not only a realization of a homeowner’s vision but also the firm’s commitment to the community and the entire home-building experience. From the initial sketch and architecture to construction and settlement, the Pohlig Custom Homes team assures meticulous attention, precise workmanship, and lasting value. 


C. Raymond Davis & Sons

2124 Kimberton Rd., Kimberton, PA 19442

  C. Raymond Davis & Sons, Inc.

Year Established

1928

Services Provided

Custom Homes, Demolition, Foundation Construction, Historic Building Conservation, Home Remodeling, Multigenerational Homes, New Home Construction, Prefab Houses, Project Management

Areas Served

Delaware Valley

What Customers Are Saying

Produces Quality Product, Nice People

Average Customer Satisfaction

4.4 (7 reviews)

Service Rating Score

4

Complaint Percentage

27.9%

C. Raymond Davis and Sons is a general contractor and construction management firm. Though the firm primarily focuses on commercial and institutional markets, it touts a national reputation as a custom home builder. It works on and constructs houses of all sizes and styles, from traditional and transitional to colonial and Victorian homes. This and many other reasons make it one of the best Philadelphia custom home builders.

The C. Raymond Davis and Sons team is unwavering in its dedication to ethical business practices and absolute integrity, doing its part as a member of several industry organizations, like the Eastern Pennsylvania and New Jersey Chapters of the Associated Builders and Contractors and the American Institute of Architects in Philadelphia and Bucks County. It is committed to delivering excellence in all aspects of its construction work, generating creative home solutions that allow clients to save money without compromising quality or design considerations. Furthermore, its project managers, estimators, and superintendents are seasoned veterans, having over thirty years of individual experience. They have successfully managed hundreds of projects and are capable of handling any size or type of construction work.


Ranking Methodology

To evaluate the performance of contractors, our methodology employs a systematic approach that considers various factors contributing to customer experience and satisfaction. We focused on assessing the custom home builders in the Philadelphia area. The methodology involves assigning weightings to specific categories based on their significance in determining customer service quality. Here’s the breakdown of the categories and their respective weightings:

  • Average Customer Satisfaction (35%): This metric represents the average rating given by customers across the same review platforms as the Average Customer Satisfaction Score. A higher average rating indicates greater overall satisfaction with the service provided.
  • Service Rating Score (25%): We analyze the ratio of high (4-5 stars) to low (1-2 stars) ratings for each business across multiple review platforms: Google, Houzz, and Yelp. A higher percentage of positive reviews contributes to a higher score, reflecting better customer satisfaction.
  • Complaint Percentage (25%): We analyze the ratio of complaints to total reviews for each business. A lower complaints ratio indicates better service quality and results in a higher score.
  • Business Hours and Availability (10%): The operating hours of each business are assessed to gauge accessibility. Companies with extended operating hours are awarded a higher score, as they offer greater convenience to customers.
  • License Status (5%): We verify the licensing status of each contractor with their local licensing board to ensure legal compliance. Companies with valid licenses receive a higher score, reflecting professionalism and adherence to regulations.
  • Total Score: We determined the overall rating for every contractor by calculating a weighted average, with the category weight determining the amount the subscore contributed to the total score 

Additional Note: Service Rating Score, Average Customer Satisfaction, and Complaint Percentage are calculated with a Bayesian estimate to account for if the contractor has a low number of total reviews. A Bayesian average is a statistical method used to calculate the average of a set of data points while taking into account prior information or beliefs about the distribution of the data. It combines the observed data with a prior distribution to generate a more accurate estimate of the true average.