Meta All Microsites Pixel

The 10 Best Custom Home Builders in Tenafly, New Jersey

7 Min Read

You want to build your dream home and the first step is finding the right builder to make this dream come true. It’s a big decision. Many firms offer the same services; only a few can give the highest-quality results and the best possible service.

To help you, we’ve curated a list of the best custom home builders in Tenafly, New Jersey. Each builder on this list has been chosen for their years of service, the recognition they have received, and the home building design specialties they can offer you. For a home built by the best contractors Tenafly, take a look at our list below!


GMD Homes

8 Louise Lane, Tenafly, NJ 07670 

GMD Homes is a woman-owned and operated construction firm serving the tri-state area with finely built homes. Since opening its doors in 1996, the firm has completed many custom homes, condominium remodels, and home improvements. The team is well-versed in designing and building for its trend-savvy clients.

The firm specializes in custom homes ranging in a number of styles, including American Foursquare, Ranch, and Contemporary. One of its notable projects is the 444 Englewood residence. It features a spacious interior with luxe glass and silver finishes. The open floor layout creates a harmonious flow from one part of the home to the next. Its design is perfect for families and even professionals looking to live in a comfortable and high-end home.


Distinctive Domain

9 Old Forge Drive, Warren, NJ 07059  

Since 2003, Distinctive Domain has built a solid reputation for building luxury custom homes and remodels in Somerset and Morris Counties. One of the firm’s services is “The 5 Simple Steps”™ created to simplify and make the construction process a breeze. It’s a collaborative approach to design and construction. Everything is done promptly, within budget, and the result always exceeds client expectations.

Simple, yet captivating’ perfectly describes this traditional home in Warren. The  Mountain Trail home is a custom-designed home that takes full advantage of the serene hillside view. Other projects in its portfolio highlight the firm’s expertise in blending modern with traditional designs. 


Lead Dog Builders

219 E Bergen Place, Red Bank, NJ 07701

Lead Dog Builders started its operations in 2009 in Michael Villane’s dining room. Through perseverance and quality construction, the company has grown its office and its clientele. The firm is now one of New Jersey’s leading custom home builders and remodelers. Villane has brought together a team of skilled designers and builders who actively collaborate in creating a vast selection of homes.

Lead Dog Builders have built and remodeled countless homes in the area. Its portfolio is filled with projects ranging from Dutch Colonial to contemporary homes. A perfect illustration of its design/build prowess is the Sea Bright home. It features a sleek and modern contemporary design. Its expansive glass windows take full advantage of panoramic views of the lake. 


Premier Design Custom Homes

405 Quantuck Ln., Westfield, NJ 07090 

Gerald Infantino is a seasoned builder with years of experience building and remodeling homes. He founded Premier Design Custom Homes to further serve New Jersey with quality custom homes. Under his meticulous management, the firm has developed its services and grown its clientele. The firm’s excellence in construction has received plenty of positive feedback from customers who praise the firm’s great attention to detail and its professional services. 

Premier Design Custom Homes’ portfolio includes a collection of finely built homes ranging in size, scope, and style. Take, for example, this Dutch Colonial home in Westfield. This elegant 5-bedroom home was recently completed in 2020 featuring an authentic colonial design. The same intricacy was poured into the home’s interiors. It features a clean and open floor layout perfect for everyday family life and for hosting events. 


Orchard Hills Design and Construction

160 Broad Street, Summit, NJ 07901 

Orchard Hills Design and Construction is a Summit-based firm dedicated to building luxury homes at an affordable price. Since its inception, the company has built a reputation for close collaboration with clients and the stunning homes that come as a result. The firm is a member of the New Jersey Builders Association and the Metropolitan Builders Association. 

Its team of design/build professionals specializes in a number of home styles ranging from Tudor to Colonial. A perfect illustration of this is the Vintage Colonial home completed in collaboration with Rosen Kelly Conway Architecture & Design. It features an authentic Colonial home with intricate interior details.


Meisenbacher Homes

7 Hillcrest Ct., Skillman, NJ 08558

Luke Meisenbacher founded Meisenbacher Homes in 1999 and introduced a progressive way of building and remodeling homes in doing so. The firm is licensed to work in both New Jersey and North Dakota. Meisenbacher has brought together a team of builders with a keen eye for detail. Each builder is dedicated to bringing diverse cultures together in its processes.  

The firm is well-versed in combining custom luxury homes with state-of-the-art technology. Its portfolio is filled with homes that range from traditional to colonial designs. One of its notable works is this Jefferson home featuring a traditional and classy exterior. Its interior displays a warm and inviting design complete with a mix of materials and warm tones. 


Villane Building & Development

2376 S Avenue, Scotch Plains, NJ 07076 

Villane Building & Development is a New Jersey-based firm influenced by Dominick Villane, a seasoned builder from Italy.  While David and Don Villane founded the firm in 1996, the family’s home building services had already been in operation since the 1940s. The firm’s ability to perform complex building projects has built its name for creating high-end quality homes. The firm includes skilled builders capable of creating a better, more efficient service for its clients.

Villane Building & Development’s projects adorn a number of neighborhoods in Westfield and Union City. Take a look at this Mohawk Lane home in Scotch Plains. It features a charming traditional exterior while its interior is built to offer privacy for each room while still rendering the flow as seamless as possible. 


Berardi Building Company

One Main Street, Suite #9, Sparta, NJ 07871 

Berardi Building Company is one of New Jersey’s leading custom home builders and it’s known for its meticulous services. Tom Alfsen is at the firm’s helm, guiding its team, improving its services, and continuously developing its home building process. His deep background in different facets of construction has helped him establish the firm as one of the best. 

Beyond its stunning homes, the firm also incorporates sustainability in its processes as a USGBC LEED Accredited Professional. One of its featured homes is this mesmerizing custom-built estate in Franklin Lakes. Its authentic, sophisticated French country design is evident in the intricate details of the exterior and interior.  


Gialluisi Custom Homes

427 S Avenue W, Westfield, NJ 07090 

Over the years, Gialluisi Custom Homes’ luxury work has set the standard for quality construction. Peter Gialluisi and Todd Ellner co-lead the company’s pool of experts to develop progressive design/build strategies. Its eco-friendly and green building practices are a recent addition to its list of services. Its innovation in processes allows the firm to deliver projects faster than the usual time spent building and renovating homes. 

Gialluisi Custom Homes’ portfolio is filled with projects in a range of styles. It highlights the firm’s flexibility in working on a number of different projects. One of Gialluisi’s featured projects is the Oak Hill home in Chatham. This energy-efficient home features multi-zone HVAC, cultured stones, a Portico entrance, and a paved driveway with Belgium block curbing. 


Geiss Custom Builders

327 Millburn Avenue, 2nd Flr., Millburn, NJ 07041 

Geiss Custom Builders are a familiar name when it comes to award-winning custom homes. It is one of the longest-serving construction firms in New Jersey, having been established in 1990. The firm is under the management of Graduate Master Builder Cliff Geissler. Because of its excellence in homebuilding, the team has received a number of recognitions including the Metropolitan Builder Contractor Association Award of Excellence and a feature in Architectural Digest.

One of its award-winning projects is the Long Hill Drive residence. Its traditional design sports a sleek, sophisticated look. In 2013, it was awarded the Community Builders & Remodelers Association of NJ Award of Excellence. Other projects in its portfolio share the same meticulous design and finely crafted spaces.